ChatGPT vs. The Human Touch: Shaping the Future of Business English Learning
ChatGPT vs. The Human Touch: The Pros and Cons of Using ChatGPT vs Human-Led Learning
PROS of Using ChatGPT
1. Accessibility and Flexibility: For instance, a sales executive, who frequently travels for business, could use ChatGPT to learn English during his transit times. He could log in to the ChatGPT platform in the airport lounge, on a flight, or even at a hotel in another time zone.
2. Unlimited Repetition: For example, a business professional aiming to master a challenging business presentation could rehearse her speech numerous times with ChatGPT, ensuring she has nailed down the business lingo and expressions perfectly.
3. Customised Learning Paths: As an illustration, a Japanese marketer trying to learn business English could interact with ChatGPT in varying degrees of complexity. Initially, ChatGPT could use simpler phrases to explain marketing terminologies. As he progresses, the AI tool could gradually introduce more advanced vocabulary and business expressions.
4. Affordability: A real-world example is that of a small business owner who cannot afford to hire an English tutor for her team. With ChatGPT, she could offer her team an economical tool to improve their business English skills.
ChatGPT vs. The Human Touch: CONS of Using ChatGPT
1. Lack of Human Interaction: A German business consultant learning English to liaise with clients globally might miss out on the nuances of casual business conversation or the culture-specific language norms in different countries when using ChatGPT.
2. Limited Real-Time Feedback: A French entrepreneur looking to perfect her English pitch to venture capitalists might not get effective feedback on non-verbal cues and tone modulation from ChatGPT.
3. Uncertainty in Dealing with Complex Queries: For example, if an Indian tech executive asks ChatGPT to explain the differences between the English used in Silicon Valley tech start-ups versus traditional British finance firms, the AI may not provide an adequately nuanced answer.
ChatGPT vs. The Human Touch: PROS of Human-Led Learning
1. Personal Connection: For instance, an Italian businessman learning English from a human tutor might find the journey more engaging due to the rapport they build, and the personalised motivational strategies the tutor uses.
2. In-depth Feedback: A Chinese executive learning English to negotiate deals might benefit from a human tutor's feedback on subtle aspects like body language, vocal inflection, and stress patterns in speech.
3. Complex Problem-Solving: As a case study, consider a Russian businesswoman learning English for international trade discussions. She might need to understand the cultural and political connotations of certain terms and phrases, an area where a human tutor's nuanced understanding could be invaluable.
ChatGPT vs. The Human Touch: CONS of Human-Led Learning
1. Availability and Flexibility: Consider a busy C-suite executive trying to fit English lessons into a packed schedule. Traditional learning with fixed class times could prove challenging for her.
2. Cost: As a real-world example, a start-up founder might struggle to afford the high fees of a seasoned business English tutor or a premium language course.
3. Pace of Learning: An example here is a fast-learning software developer who might feel held back by the pace of a group English class. Conversely, a slower learner might feel pressured to keep up.